The Pure Heart and Straight Reason in Jonathan Edwards’s Theology


1 Associate Professor, Department of Islamic Philosophy, Imam Khomeini International University, Qazvin

2 Postgraduate in philosophy of religion, Imam Khomeini International University, Qazvin,


The article "Sound Heart and Straight Mind in Jonathan Edwards Theology" by Ruhollah Adineh and Hamed Afsharian was published in the 14th issue (Autumn and Winter of 1398) of the Journal of Religious Studies (JRS) after similarity check and review. At that time, the similarity percentage was detected by Samim Noor System as less than 8%, which seemed normal. Following the publication, one of the JRS's serious readers claimed in an email that the article was mainly taken and translated from the first chapter of William Wainwright's book "Reason and the Heart: A Prolegomenon to a Critique of Passional Reason".
After investigation, the above claim was established. Hence, the article is deleted due to non-observance of research ethics. Hereby JRS thanks the respected reader and apologizes to other esteemed readers.
Chief Editor


Alexander Pope. 1969. “The Dunciad (1742).” In Poetry and Prose of Alexanderpope, edited by Aubrey William. Boston: Houghton Mifflin.
Asadiniya, Saham, and Ilmi, Qurban. 2016. “The Viewpoints of Jonathan Edwards and Faiz Kashani on The Relationship between Reason and Faith (Didgah-i Jonathan Edwards va Faiz Kashani dar bab-i Rabiti-yi Aql va Iman.” Pazhuhish-ha-yi Falsafi va Kalamai, no. 70. 77-96. [in Farsi]
Edwards, Jonathan. 1935. Personal Narrative. New York: American Book Co.
Edwards, Jonathan. 1955. The Philosophy of Jonothan Edwards from His Private Note Books, Edited by Harvey G. Townsend, Eugene. Ore: University of Oregon Monographs.
Edwards, Jonathan. 1959. Religious Affections: the Works of Jonathan Edwards's Series Vol. 2, Edited by John E. Smith, New Haven: Yale University Press.
Edwards, Jonathan. 1970. Original Sin. New Haven: Yale University Press.
Edwards, Jonathan. 1986. A Divine and Supernatural Light and Miscellaneous Observations:The Works of President Edwards. New York: P. Franklin.
Edwards, Jonathan. 1989. “The Nature of True Virtue.” In Ethical Writings, edited by Paul Ramsey. New Haven: Yale University Press.
Edwards, Jonathan. 2000. “The 'Miscellanies': Entry Nos.” In The Works of Jonathan Edwards vol. 18, edited by Ava Chamberlain, 501–832: New Haven: Yale University Press.
Fanning, Steven. 2005. Mystics of Christian Tradition. Translated by Farid Radmihr. Tehran: Nilufar Publications. [in Farsi]
Furuzanfar, Badi’uzzaman. 2008. Hadiths and Stories of The Mathnavi (Ahadith va Qisas-i Masnavi). Translated by Hussein Davudi. Tehran: Amirkabir Publications.
James, William. 1981. The Priciples of Psychology. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.
Lane, Belden. 2004. "Jonathan Edwards on Beauty, Desire, and the Sensory World." In Theological Studies, no. 65: 44-72.
Morgan, John. 1986. Godly Learning; Puritan Attitudes toward Reason, Learning and
Education. Cambridge University Press.
Nuttall, Geoffrey F. 1992. The Holy Spiritin Puritan Faith and Experience. University of Chicago Press.
Pannenberg, Wolfhart. 2007. An Introduction to Systematic Theology. Translated by Abdurrahim Sulaimani Ardistani. Qom: Religions and Denominations University Publications.
Sanayi, Abulmajd ibn Adam. 1996. The Collected Poetic Works of Sanayi Ghaznavi The Wise, foreworded by Badi’uzzaman Furuzanfar. Tehran: Nigah Publishing House.
Stiver, Dan. The Philosophy of Religious Language. Translated by Abulfazl Sajidi. Qom: Adyan Publications. [in Farsi]
Wainwright, James William. 1995. Reason and the Heart: A Prolegomenon to a Critique of Passional Reason. USA: Cornell University.
Wainwright, William J. 2007. Reason and the Heart. Translated by Muhammad Hadi Shahab. Qom: Research Center for Islamic Sciences and Culture. [in Farsi]